WC涂层-Si3N4配副在统一润滑条件下的低摩与极低磨损:频率-载荷相图与寿命验证

王志伟, 牛振威, 冯一可, 杨再秀, 张斌

表面技术 ›› 2026, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (21) : 36-49.

PDF(17194 KB)
PDF(17194 KB)
表面技术 ›› 2026, Vol. 55 ›› Issue (21) : 36-49. DOI: 10.16490/j.cnki.issn.1001-3660.2026.21.004
专题——能源装备功能部件表/界面技术

WC涂层-Si3N4配副在统一润滑条件下的低摩与极低磨损:频率-载荷相图与寿命验证

  • 王志伟1,2, 牛振威1,*, 冯一可3, 杨再秀2, 张斌2,*
作者信息 +

Low Friction and Ultra-low Wear of WC-coated/Si3N4 Pair under Unified Lubrication: Frequency-load Map with Lifetime Verification

  • WANG Zhiwei1,2, NIU Zhenwei1,*, FENG Yike3, YANG Zaixiu2, ZHANG Bin2,*
Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

目的 面向核电装备辅助机构在启停、低速换向和长时运行阶段的材料筛选需求,研究PAO-6润滑下WC涂层钢球-Si3N4配副的载荷-往复频率响应及长时耐久性。方法 采用球-盘往复摩擦构型,设置5、10、15 N与3、5、7 Hz的3 × 3工况矩阵,每组运行8 h;另设未涂层钢球对照组D1(5 N、5 Hz、8 h)和WC涂层长时组D2(10 N、5 Hz、226 h)。记录摩擦系数,并以XRD、纳米压痕、三维轮廓、OM及SEM/EDS表征试样和磨痕。结果 各8 h涂层组的摩擦系数总体为0.08~0.09,载荷和频率范围内未呈现明确的单调变化;D1的摩擦系数及波动均高于同工况涂层组B1。A2(10 N、3 Hz)、A3(15 N、3 Hz)和D2可分辨出磨痕,其比磨损率分别为7.20×10‒9、4.35×10‒9和0.77×10‒9 mm3/(N·m);D2运行226 h后磨痕最大深度约0.2 μm、磨损体积约3.12×10‒4 mm3,试验按计划终止时未出现持续摩擦上升。EDS在A2、D1和D2盘面检测到C、O信号。结论 在本研究的室温、PAO-6和球-盘简化接触条件下,WC涂层有助于降低摩擦并维持较低磨损,226 h结果表明该配副具有长时耐久性。该结果可作为核电相关低速启停部件候选材料的基础筛选依据。

Abstract

Aiming at the demand for low friction, high reliability, and long service life of oil-lubricated contact pairs in nuclear power equipment, especially during start-stop, low-speed, and long-cycle operation of mechanical seals, auxiliary pump/valve components, and small-stroke guiding/support units, this work systematically investigates the tribological behavior of a WC-coated steel ball/Si3N4 disk pair under PAO-6 lubrication and resolves the coupled effects of load and frequency. A reciprocating ball-on-disk configuration at room temperature was used to conduct 11 conditions in total: a 3×3 full-factorial matrix with loads of 5, 10, 15 N and frequencies of 3, 5, 7 Hz (each run for 8 h) and two supplementary groups, namely D1 (uncoated steel ball vs. Si3N4, 5 N, 5 Hz, 8 h) and D2 (WC vs. Si3N4 lifetime test, 10 N, 5 Hz, operated for 226 h with controlled refilling). For all 8 h tests, a single drop of PAO-6 was dispensed at the beginning and no refilling was needed because the oil film remained sufficient; for the 226 h lifetime test, PAO-6 was replenished as needed to maintain film continuity without altering the mechanical loading. Time-resolved friction coefficients were recorded in situ; after testing, optical microscopy (OM), 3D profilometry, and SEM/EDS were employed, while XRD was performed only on the as-received WC-coated ball and Si3N4 disk to establish the baseline phases. The principal finding was extremely mild wear across most 8 h conditions: in the majority of cases, the wear track was undetectable by SEM, by 3D cross-sections/volume, and by OM, demonstrating that PAO-6 lubrication combined with the WC coating could keep geometric damage below the detection threshold. Only A2 (10 N, 3 Hz), A3 (15 N, 3 Hz), and the lifetime group D2 (10 N, 5 Hz, 226 h) exhibited weak, strip-like wear features. Under identical loads, 7 Hz COF traces exhibited more pronounced temporal fluctuations, attributed to a higher count of stick-slip events within the same observation time, which amplified visible oscillations even when average friction remained low. The uncoated control D1 delivered a consistently higher COF and stronger fluctuations than the coated counterpart at 5 N/5 Hz, underscoring the stabilizing and friction-reducing role of the WC surface. Notably, D1 showed a wide dark band in OM but no continuous groove in SEM, indicating composition/film-driven optical contrast rather than pronounced geometric abrasion. EDS over the wear track revealed that Si and N dominated in all analyzed cases. W was negligible on the Si3N4 surface in all three EDS surveys, implying minimal material transfer from the WC ball, which aligned with the ultralow wear volumes. In the 226 h lifetime test D2, the tribo-pair was far from failure at termination; the maximum track depth was 0.2 μm and the wear volume was 3.12× 10‒4 mm3, confirming durable low-wear performance under sustained lubrication. Baseline XRD identified WC and β-Si3N4 as the dominant pre-test phases, ensuring materials purity/stability for interpreting the tribological mechanisms. Overall, the results establish that WC-coated steel/Si3N4 under PAO-6 lubrication can achieve low friction, ultra-low wear, and long-term stability; and they additionally provide a practical mechanistic framework-for selecting operating windows, suppressing friction oscillations, and engineering long-life lubricated components.

关键词

碳化钨涂层 / 氮化硅 / PAO-6油润滑 / 核电装备 / 黏滑 / 极低磨损

Key words

tungsten carbide coating / silicon nitride / PAO-6 lubrication / nuclear power equipment / stick-slip / ultra-low wear

引用本文

导出引用
王志伟, 牛振威, 冯一可, 杨再秀, 张斌. WC涂层-Si3N4配副在统一润滑条件下的低摩与极低磨损:频率-载荷相图与寿命验证[J]. 表面技术. 2026, 55(21): 36-49
WANG Zhiwei, NIU Zhenwei, FENG Yike, YANG Zaixiu, ZHANG Bin. Low Friction and Ultra-low Wear of WC-coated/Si3N4 Pair under Unified Lubrication: Frequency-load Map with Lifetime Verification[J]. Surface Technology. 2026, 55(21): 36-49
中图分类号: TH117   

参考文献

[1] LUBBINGE H.On the Lubrication of Mechanical Face Seals[D]. University Library/University of Twente, 1999. DOI:10.3990/1.9789036512404
[2] PARK Y, HONG G, JUN S, et al.Lubrication Analysis of a Mechanical Seal Considering the Mixed Lubricant State of Gas and Liquid during External Power Shutdown of a Reactor Cooling Pump[J]. Lubricants, 2024, 12(12): 406.
[3] BI E Z, LI S X, ZHAI Z X, et al.Analysis of Wear Characteristics of Hydrodynamic Seals during Startup Using 3D Fractal Characterization and Study of Opening Performance Degradation Mechanism[J]. Tribology Transactions, 2024, 67(4): 787-804.
[4] LIAO C J, SUO S F, WANG Y M, et al.Study on Stick-Slip Friction of Reciprocating O-Ring Seals Using Acoustic Emission Techniques[J]. Tribology Transactions, 2012, 55(1): 43-51.
[5] MURAKI M, KINBARA E, KONISHI T.A Laboratory Simulation for Stick-Slip Phenomena on the Hydraulic Cylinder of a Construction Machine[J]. Tribology International, 2003, 36(10): 739-744.
[6] FEUCHTMÜLLER O, HÖRL L, BAUER F. An Empirical Study on the Friction of Reciprocating Rod Seals at Predefined Lubrication Conditions and Shear Rates[J]. Lubricants, 2022, 10(4): 56.
[7] LEI Y J, LENG Y S.Stick-Slip Friction and Energy Dissipation in Boundary Lubrication[J]. Physical Review Letters, 2011, 107(14): 147801.
[8] ZARETSKY E V, VLCEK B L, HENDRICKS R C.Effect of Silicon Nitride Balls and Rollers on Rolling Bearing Life[J]. Tribology Transactions, 2005, 48(3): 425-435.
[9] SU B, LU C H, LI C H.Current Status of Research on Hybrid Ceramic Ball Bearings[J]. Machines, 2024, 12(8): 510.
[10] 文怀兴, 孙建建, 陈威. 氮化硅陶瓷轴承润滑技术的研究现状与发展趋势[J]. 材料导报, 2015, 29(17): 6-14.
WEN H X, SUN J J, CHEN W.Review on Research Status and Development Trend on Silicon Nitride Ceramic Bearings[J]. Materials Review, 2015, 29(17): 6-14.
[11] 张创, 宋仪杰. 氮化硅陶瓷的研究与应用进展[J]. 中国陶瓷工业, 2021, 28(3): 40-47.
ZHANG C, SONG Y J.Progress in Research and Application of Silicon Nitride Ceramics[J]. China Ceramic Industry, 2021, 28(3): 40-47.
[12] 梁艳媛, 蒋睿哲, 刘青铜, 等. 基于PIP工艺的氮化物纤维复合材料的制备关键问题[J]. 当代化工研究, 2025(7): 158-160.
LIANG Y Y, JIANG R Z, LIU Q T, et al.Key Challenges in the Fabrication of Nitride Fiber Composites via PIP Process[J]. Modern Chemical Research, 2025(7): 158-160.
[13] HAGGERTY J, LIGHTFOOT A.Opportunities for Enhancing the Thermal Conductivities of SiC and Si3N4 Ceramics Through Improved Processing[J]. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2008.
[14] TÄFFNER U, CARLE V, SCHÄFER U, et al. Keramographie von Hochleistungskeramiken—Werkstoffbeschreibung, Präparation, Atztechniken Und Gefügebeschreibung—Teil V: Siliciumnitrid (Si3N4) /Ceramography of High Performance Ceramics-Description of Materials, Preparation, Etching Techniques and Description of Microstructures: Part V: Silicon Nitride (Si3N4)[J]. Practical Metallography, 1991, 28(11): 592-610.
[15] SEMMLER. Silicon Nitride-Material of the Future[J]. Chem -Anlagen Verfahren, 1974: 80-87.
[16] SUBRAMANIAM S, NITHYAPRAKASH R, ABBAS G, et al.Tribological Behavior of Silicon Nitride-Based Ceramics: A Review[J]. Jurnal Tribologi, 2021, 29: 57-71.
[17] ZIEGLER G, HEINRICH J, WÖTTING G. Relationships between Processing, Microstructure and Properties of Dense and Reaction-Bonded Silicon Nitride[J]. Journal of Materials Science, 1987, 22(9): 3041-3086.
[18] 郭景坤. 中国先进陶瓷研究及其展望[J]. 材料研究学报, 1997, 11(6): 594-600.
GUO J K.The Research on Advanced Ceramics and Its Prospects in China[J]. Chinese Journal of Material Research, 1997, 11(6): 594-600.
[19] FÜNFSCHILLING S, FETT T, HOFFMANN M J, et al. Mechanisms of Toughening in Silicon Nitrides: The Roles of Crack Bridging and Microstructure[J]. Acta Materialia, 2011, 59(10): 3978-3989.
[20] ERDEMIR A, RAMIREZ G, ERYILMAZ O L, et al.Carbon-Based Tribofilms from Lubricating Oils[J]. Nature, 2016, 536(7614): 67-71.
[21] WATSON S, DENNINGTON S, WANG L, et al.Polymer Brush Lubrication of the Silicon Nitride-Steel Contact: A Colloidal Force Microscopy Study[J]. RSC Advances, 2017, 7(68): 42667-42676.
[22] WANG L, WOOD R J K, HARVEY T J, et al. Wear Performance of Oil Lubricated Silicon Nitride Sliding Against Various Bearing Steels[J]. Wear, 2003, 255(1/2/3/4/5/6): 657-668.
[23] WU D F, LIU Y S, YANG S D, et al. Friction and Wear Characteristics of WC-10Co-4Cr/Si3N4 Tribopair Lubricated under Silt-Laden Water[J]. Wear, 2012, 294/295: 370-379.
[24] KRONBERGER M, BRENNER J.Tribocorrosive Aspects of Tungsten Carbide, Silicon Nitride, and Martensitic Steel under Fretting-Like Conditions[J]. Lubricants, 2023, 11(5): 195.
[25] YANG C R, CHIOU Y C, LEE R T.Tribological Behavior of Reciprocating Friction Drive System under Lubricated Contact[J]. Tribology International, 1999, 32(8): 443-453.
[26] ROSENHEK-GOLDIAN I, KAMPF N, YEREDOR A, et al.On the Question of Whether Lubricants Fluidize in Stick-Slip Friction[J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2015, 112(23): 7117-7122.
[27] WOOD R J K. Tribology of Thermal Sprayed WC-Co Coatings[J]. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 2010, 28(1): 82-94.
[28] BOLELLI G, BERGER L M, BÖRNER T, et al. Tribology of HVOF- and HVAF-Sprayed WC-10Co4Cr Hardmetal Coatings: A Comparative Assessment[J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2015, 265: 125-144.
[29] MAKHLOUF A S H, ALIOFKHAZRAEI M. Handbook of Materials Failure Analysis with Case Studies from the Oil and Gas Industry[M]. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2016.
[30] PODGORNIK B, VIŽINTIN J, JACOBSON S, et al. Tribological Behaviour of WC/C Coatings Operating under Different Lubrication Regimes[J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2004, 177: 558-565.
[31] ZENG Q F, YU F, DONG G N.Superlubricity Behaviors of Si3N4/DLC Films under PAO Oil with Nano Boron Nitride Additive Lubrication[J]. Surface and Interface Analysis, 2013, 45(8): 1283-1290.
[32] ALAZIZI A, BARTHEL A J, SURDYKA N D, et al.Vapors in the Ambient—A Complication in Tribological Studies or an Engineering Solution of Tribological Problems?[J]. Friction, 2015, 3(2): 85-114.
[33] GUNDERSON S, FULTZ G, SNYDER C E, et al.The Effect of Water Content on the Dielectric Strength of Polyalphaolefin (PAO) Coolants[J]. IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation, 2011, 18(1): 295-302.

基金

国家自然科学基金重大研究计划(92580101)

PDF(17194 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/

〈 〉